The Lord of the Rings: Return to Moria™ similar games & best alternatives

Why it matches

• Both are better with other people Strong emphasis on cooperative multiplayer modes including online and local split-screen co-op, with teamwork being a core feature.
• Both build a real sense of fellowship Strong community and social play aspects with cooperative multiplayer and shared experiences.
• Both lean into fantasy Set in the fictional world of Middle-earth with magic, mythical creatures, and epic fantasy narrative.

Why it matches

• Both are better with other people Co-op multiplayer up to 4 players is a highlight, with teamwork emphasized; many reviews praise playing with friends.
• Both build a real sense of fellowship Community and multiplayer cooperation are important; players enjoy shared experiences and social interaction.
• Both lean into fantasy Strongly themed around Greek mythology and underworld fantasy, with imaginative enemies, weapons, and setting.

Why it matches

• Both are about exploring Large open world with secrets, dungeons, and varied environments encourages curiosity-driven discovery.
• Both are built to keep you coming back Many players report hundreds of hours, multiple playthroughs, and high replayability with different classes and builds.
• Both pull you into another world Immersive fantasy world, epic battles, and exploration provide strong escape from real life.

Why it matches

• Both are better with other people Strong emphasis on co-op play with friends or online; multiplayer is stable and encouraged.
• Both build a real sense of fellowship Community and group identity through co-op play; players enjoy social interaction and shared achievements.
• Both are about exploring Large handcrafted dungeons with secrets and hidden bosses encourage discovery and curiosity.

Why it matches

• Both are better with other people Co-op multiplayer is a key feature praised by players, enabling teamwork and shared dungeon crawling experiences.
• Both lean into fantasy Fantasy roguelike setting with pixel art monsters, magic, and dungeon crawling immerses players in imaginative fiction.
• Both are driven by steady progression Roguelike progression with item collection, weapon upgrades, and character leveling motivates continued play.

Why it matches

• Both are better with other people Supports seamless online co-op play from start to finish; cooperative gameplay is a highlighted feature.
• Both are about exploring Highly praised interconnected world design with many shortcuts and secrets encourages extensive discovery.
• Both lean into fantasy Set in a fictional, meta game world with imaginative characters, bosses, and narrative blending humor and tragedy.

Why it matches

• Both pull you into another world Game offers immersive parkour, zombie combat, and exploration in a post-apocalyptic world providing strong escape from reality.
• Both are about exploring Large open world with verticality, hidden caches, side quests, and dynamic events encourage discovery.
• Both are built to keep you coming back Players report long playtimes, replayability through choices, side quests, and ongoing updates that keep engagement high.

Why it matches

• Both are about exploring Open world with multiple biomes and secrets; players enjoy discovering new areas and lore.
• Both lean into fantasy Strong fantasy setting with magic, mythical creatures, and RuneScape lore references.
• Both are driven by steady progression Strong emphasis on leveling skills, acquiring better gear, and unlocking new crafting recipes.

Why it matches

• Both are better with other people Co-op is a core feature with teamwork emphasized in boss fights, shared progression, and synergy between archetypes.
• Both build a real sense of fellowship Community and social play important through co-op, shared achievements, and cooperative boss fights.
• Both are about exploring Procedural world design, secret areas, puzzles, and randomized dungeons reward curiosity and discovery.